I've delayed posting anything about this, as it contains some things that could be considered inflammatory if the person doesn't read the whole post.
So if you read past this, you owe it to me to read the whole thing.
Last weekend LifeStream Christian Church sponsored a concert in the Village of Batavia. This involved the need to close Broadway Street, a lowly traveled street during non-school times.
The Village Administrator also happens to be an Elder at LifeStream Christian Church, so he was involved in this event in two roles.
1. Elder. It was a way to get our church name out in the public, and the fee wasn't to bad ($1200 according to the paper... more on that in a second).
2. Village Administrator. This event was also 'sponsored' by the Village of Batavia for the purpose of letting the band use the village land and advertise with a large banner over Main Street in Batavia.
I arrived about 20 minutes before the concert started and I saw my friend Bob (the Administrator/Elder) getting a verbal lashing from a middle aged (but not small) man. Also involved were two, IMO, not fit for battle police officers and the mayor John Thebout. I initially assumed this was an angry citizen so I headed in his direction to give some, um, personal backup. As I approached I heard this man say to arrest Bob for disorderly conduct! So I figured it was the police chief, Michael Gardner, and kept my distance.
Turns out the dispute was over the closing of the street. Gardner feels that Bob has to get a permit to close roads. Bob feels that in his role as Village Administrator and more specifically street commissioner can shut down a road anytime he wants to. And this concert, planned well in advance, was a reason to shut down this small and sparsely traveled road.
The truth in the matter is that nobody, in power, apparently knows who is right. So now Judge Anthony W. Brock will have to decide who is right in a pending court case.
Now this could have been avoided had Gardner taken a few precautionary steps before hand (he apparently knew he was going to cause issues with this for a period of time before the actual concert). Gardner had two options that would have satisfied his problem.
1. Talk to Village Solicitor George Leicht and ask for his legal opinion with the situation. That is Leicht's job by the way.
2. Go to the village council and ask them to pass an ordinance making the 'right decision' here very clear. Now this is pretty easy for Gardner considering his wife, Michelle is on council.
However, and this is where I fault him, he decided to put the village in the spot light in a negative manner over what, at its root, is a political power struggle. There is a very small minority that wants Bob Stewart AND Mayor Thebout out of their positions. This movement hit its peak in the past elections when two pretty vocal opponents ran against Thebout, though one was significantly more negative then the other. After the elections Thebout won handily, and you'd hope that this minority could accept that elections have consequences and move forward for the betterment of the village. However they couldn't so the next council meeting will likely be a waste of time focused on this incident.
I just wish that Gardner would spend his Sunday evenings fighting crime rather than a public service to the village of Batavia. I lived in the village until I recently moved, and right across the street from me was a group of people that were constantly involved in shady things, and there were sometimes when I couldn't get much resolve from Mr. Gardner to fix the issue.
So why do I post this now? Two reasons, the second because of the first.
1. The Cincinnati Enquirer has picked up on this event and written an article (Front page, section C).
2. The article mentions my church. So I figured I'd give at least a non-partial third party opinion to the situation.
Aren't politics grand?
Though I will confess, I had my share of fun ridiculing Bob for getting arrested. :-)